Expansion Tanks and Pressure Valves for Non-Plumbers
Why this matters
Next to most water heaters hangs a small tank, usually blue, white or gray, about the size of a basketball, screwed onto the cold water pipe. Painters, cleaners, handymen and electricians who work in that closet see it as something to hang a hose on, lean a ladder against, or bump with a shelf. It is not decoration. It is the only thing absorbing the water that expands every time the heater fires, and when it stops doing that, the relief valve on the heater starts dripping, the pressure in the house climbs, and fittings and fixtures take the strain. This card explains what the tank and the two valves around it do, how trouble looks from the outside, and what nobody but a plumber should touch. The water heater as a whole, including its venting and relief discharge, is covered in The Water Heater for Trades That Share Its Closet.
Safety first
- Water or steam spraying from the relief valve or its discharge pipe: stay clear of the discharge, which can be close to boiling. Do not cap, plug or bend the pipe. Steam means the water is overheating, so the heat goes off first: the homeowner turns the heater's gas control to OFF or switches off its breaker, if that can be done without passing the discharge, and calls a plumber. Do not close the cold supply while the heater is still firing. The heater stays off until the plumber has found why the valve opened.
- Do not lift the relief valve's test lever to see whether it works. An old valve may not reseat and then runs continuously.
- Do not press the small tire-style valve on the expansion tank. Releasing its air charge disables the tank, and if the diaphragm has failed, it releases house-pressure water instead.
The layout
METER (some have a check valve built in)
|
[PRESSURE REDUCING VALVE] lowers street pressure;
| most also stop backflow
[MAIN SHUTOFF]
|
+---------> house cold water to fixtures
|
[COLD SHUTOFF] above heater
|
+--- tee ---[EXPANSION TANK] air on one side of
| screwed on a rubber diaphragm,
| by its 3/4 in house water on the
| fitting other
v
+------------------+
| WATER HEATER |--[T&P RELIEF VALVE] opens at
| cold in, hot | | 150 psi or 210 F
| out to fixtures | | (typical rating)
+------------------+ | discharge pipe, full
| size, ends near floor
v or at a drain
What thermal expansion does in a closed system
Water expands when it is heated, and it barely compresses. From water density tables, water heated from 55 F to 125 F grows by about 1.2 percent of its volume. In a 50 gallon heater filled with cold water and heated all the way, that is 50 times 0.0122, about 0.61 gallons of extra water with nowhere to be.
In an open system, that extra water pushes back out through the cold supply into the city main, and nobody notices.
A system becomes closed when something in the supply lets water in but not back out: a check valve or backflow preventer at the meter, or a pressure reducing valve, most of which also block backflow. Then the 0.61 gallons has to go somewhere inside the house's own piping. Because water barely compresses, the pressure rises very fast with very little volume. Without anything to absorb it, the pressure climbs until the heater's temperature and pressure relief valve (the T&P) opens at its rated pressure, typically 150 psi on a valve listed to ANSI Z21.22 / CSA 4.4, and dumps the excess.
That is why the IRC at P2903.4, as adopted by your jurisdiction, requires thermal expansion control on a storage water heater where a check valve, backflow preventer or other device closes the system. The expansion tank is the usual answer.
A common way a house becomes closed without anyone deciding it: the water utility replaces the meter with one that includes a check valve. The heater, the piping and the habits stay the same, and a week later the relief valve starts to drip.
How the tank works
An expansion tank is a steel shell with a rubber diaphragm inside. One side holds air, charged at the factory or by the installer through the small valve on the end. The other side is open to the house's cold water. The plumber sets the air charge to match the house's static water pressure, so that with the heater cold the diaphragm sits at rest and the tank holds almost no water.
When the heater fires and the water expands, the extra water pushes into the tank, compressing the air. The air acts as a spring. The pressure in the house rises, but by a controlled amount instead of up to the relief valve's setting.
A worked example: a healthy tank and a tired one
The numbers below assume a 2.0 gallon expansion tank, a house at 60 psi static pressure, sea-level air at 14.7 psi, piping that does not stretch, and air that stays at the same temperature while compressed. Real piping, fixtures and the heater shell give a little, so real peaks run somewhat lower than these: treat each figure as an upper estimate. Pressures are calculated in absolute terms (psia, gauge plus 14.7) and reported in gauge terms (psig, what a gauge on a hose bib reads).
Healthy tank, charged to 60 psig. At rest the 2.0 gallons is all air at 60 + 14.7 = 74.7 psia.
- After a 20 gallon hot water draw is refilled with 55 F water and heated to 125 F, the expansion is 20 times 0.0122, 0.244 gallons. The air is squeezed from 2.0 to 2.0 minus 0.244, 1.756 gallons. Pressure times volume stays constant, so 74.7 times 2.0 divided by 1.756 is 85.1 psia, or 70.4 psig.
- After a full tank of cold water heats (a new install, or after the heater was drained), the expansion is 0.61 gallons. Air goes from 2.0 to 1.39 gallons. 74.7 times 2.0 divided by 1.39 is 107.5 psia, or 92.8 psig. Well under the relief valve's 150.
Tired tank, air charge leaked down to 20 psig. At rest the air is at 20 + 14.7 = 34.7 psia in 2.0 gallons, but the house is at 60 psig, so house water has already pushed into the tank and squeezed the air to 34.7 times 2.0 divided by 74.7, which is 0.929 gallons. Over half the tank's volume is already used before the heater does anything.
- After the same 20 gallon draw (0.244 gallons of expansion), air goes from 0.929 to 0.685 gallons. 34.7 times 2.0 divided by 0.685 is 101.3 psia, or 86.6 psig. Higher than the healthy tank's 70.4, still below the relief setting.
- After a full 50 gallons heats (0.61 gallons), air would have to go from 0.929 to 0.319 gallons, which is 69.4 divided by 0.319, about 218 psia or 203 psig. The relief valve opens long before that, at 150 psig, which is 164.7 psia. That pressure is reached when the air is down to 69.4 divided by 164.7, 0.421 gallons, meaning 0.929 minus 0.421, about 0.508 gallons, has expanded into the tank. 0.508 divided by 0.0122 is about 42 gallons heated from cold.
What the example shows. A tired tank does not fail all at once. Small draws still stay below the relief setting, at 86.6 psig against 70.4 for the healthy tank, and big ones do not. In this example any recovery of more than about 42 gallons from cold lifts the relief valve, which is why the drip often shows up after a morning of showers, a load of laundry on hot, or a drain-and-refill, and not every day. A tank whose diaphragm has torn, or whose air is entirely gone, is called waterlogged: it holds no air, absorbs nothing, and the relief valve opens on every heating cycle that runs long enough.
How trouble looks from the outside
- A wet floor or a puddle at the end of the relief discharge pipe, especially after heavy hot water use or overnight. A relief valve that drips is doing its job; the question for the plumber is why the pressure reached it.
- The tank sounds dull and solid when tapped all the way to the top, rather than hollow at the air end, or it is much heavier than it looks. Tapping is fine; pressing its air valve is not.
- Banging or hammering in the pipes, toilets that run briefly by themselves, or faucets that spit when first opened, in a house that did not do this before.
- A pressure gauge with a maximum-reading needle, left on a hose bib overnight by a plumber, reading well above the house's normal static pressure. Where static pressure itself is above 80 psi, the IRC at P2903.3.1, as adopted, calls for a pressure reducing valve; a peak above it from expansion is the tank's problem, not the reducing valve's.
Why nobody hangs anything from the tank or its pipe
A healthy tank is mostly air. A waterlogged 2 gallon tank holds about 2.0 times 8.34, roughly 17 pounds of water, plus the tank's own weight, all hanging off one threaded fitting on a cold water pipe that may be thin copper with soldered joints. The manufacturer's instructions say how the tank must be supported, and many call for a strap or bracket because the fitting is not meant to carry side loads. Add a hose, an extension cord, a coat hanger, a bucket handle or a ladder leaning on it, and the load goes into that fitting and the soldered joints behind it. A bumped tank can crack the fitting or a joint and flood the closet at full house pressure.
So, for every trade working near it:
- Painters and cleaners: nothing hung on the tank or its pipe, no ladders leaned on it, no drop cloths tied to it, and no stacking against it.
- Handymen and closet installers: shelving and brackets go on studs clear of the tank and the cold pipe, with access left for the plumber to service or replace the tank.
- Electricians: a copper wire clamped across the hot and cold pipes at the heater is a bonding jumper that keeps the metal water piping electrically continuous under NEC 250.104, as adopted. Leave it on, and never use the tank or its pipe as a support for cable.
What the plumber owns
Setting and checking the tank's air charge (which is done with the water pressure off the tank), replacing a waterlogged tank, sizing a new one for the heater and the house pressure, testing or replacing the relief valve, and setting the pressure reducing valve. What a non-plumber does is recognize the signs above, leave the equipment alone, and describe what they saw in the plumber's own terms. See related: Describing a Problem in Another Trade's Own Words.
References
- IRC Sections P2903.3.1 and P2903.4, as adopted by your jurisdiction; check the current edition
- ANSI Z21.22 / CSA 4.4, relief valves for hot water supply systems
- NFPA 70 (NEC), Section 250.104, as adopted
- The expansion tank manufacturer's installation instructions for precharge and support
- See related: The Water Heater for Trades That Share Its Closet, Supply Plumbing and PEX Manifolds for the Trades That Share the Walls